A Red Carpet for Gay Weddings
The New York Times
By Joshua Kurlantzick
April 11, 2008
LAST summer, when Kimberly McHugh and Laura
Pazarena, a couple in Washington, decided to
celebrate their union, they quickly ran into the
same problems that any couple faces.
“There were so many vendors, flowers, the
D.J.s, and it was getting bigger and bigger,”
Ms. Pazarena said. “I was just getting flooded
with e-mails, I was getting so stressed.”
Ultimately, in planning their ceremony in
Provincetown, Mass., which will mix Irish and
Hawaiian themes, the couple hired a wedding
planner to help out. They plan to have at least
50 guests at the event this summer, most
spending an entire weekend on Cape Cod.
Less than a decade ago, Ms. McHugh and Ms.
Pazarena would not have had as much stress
because they wouldn’t have had as many choices.
When Vermont enacted same-sex civil union
legislation in 2000, it was the first state to
do so, and gay and lesbian couples who came to
Vermont found only a smattering of florists,
wedding planners, inns, resorts and other
vendors for civil unions.
But since 2000, Massachusetts, Connecticut,
New Jersey and New Hampshire have legalized
same-sex civil unions or marriages. (While many
out-of-state couples travel to these states for
ceremonies and call them “weddings,” their
unions may only be recognized by a handful of
states. California and Oregon — and to a more
limited degree Maine, Hawaii, Washington State
and the District of Columbia — have domestic
partnership laws.)
Throughout the Northeast, competition has
spiked among wedding sites, hotels, resorts and
inns as the travel industry has realized that
same-sex ceremonies can draw scores of guests,
who turn these destinations weddings into
weekend stays.
“When my mom started our business in 1999,
she would go to stationery shows and people
would just look at her like she was crazy,” said
Kathryn Hamm, a same-sex ceremony consultant in
Virginia who deals with clients nationwide. “A
couple years later she went back and all of
these vendors remembered her, and now they are
begging her, ‘What can we do to help?’ ”
Bernadette Smith, president and owner of It’s
About Time Events, a Massachusetts wedding
planner specializing in same-sex unions, said
that when same-sex marriage was legalized in
Massachusetts, there was not much competition
from other states, but now that has changed.
“The number of out-of-state couples contacting
me has diminished,” she said. “The novelty of
Massachusetts being the only place with gay
marriage has worn off a bit.”
TRAVEL agencies, too, are catering to gay
couples heading to the Northeast for civil-union
ceremonies, and many Northeast states now hold
gay and lesbian wedding expositions, where
couples can choose among ministers who marry
same-sex partners, jewelers who offer tiaras and
custom rings, and numerous other vendors. In
March 2007, for example, New Jersey held its
first gay and lesbian wedding expo, featuring
hundreds of vendors at the New Jersey Convention
and Exposition Center in Edison.
At the Moose Meadow Lodge, an inn in
Waterbury, Vt., one of the owners, Willie Docto,
has hosted roughly 185 civil-union ceremonies
since Vermont legalized them. Many have been
all-inclusive plans — Mr. Docto offers three
options, with prices ranging from about $2,750
to over $4,000 — where couples celebrate their
union at the lodge and then have the entire
place to themselves and many of their guests for
the weekend. The lodge holds 200 people for the
ceremonies, and it has four guest rooms that
sleep eight people. (For those seeking the most
modest of ceremonies — just two people — the
lodge will add $199 to the room rate, which
gives couples the services of an officiant and
other ceremony perks.)
Gigi B. Sohn and her partner, Lara Ballard,
had their ceremony at the Moose Meadow last
August. The couple had stayed at the lodge
before, so picking it for their ceremony was a
natural.
“We paid for the civil-union package at the
lodge, and we got all the rooms for immediate
family — people were coming in from California,
Virginia, Texas, Pittsburgh,” Ms. Sohn said.
The weekend civil-union package is catching
on. In New Hampshire, which legalized civil
unions just this year, Lesley Marquis quickly
waded into the market. At her Rosewood Country
Inn in Bradford, a Victorian mansion built in
1850, she built a civil-unions package and has
already held two ceremonies and booked two more
for this spring and summer.
“Summer is so busy that if couples want to
marry then they have to plan well in advance,”
said Rob Tosner, an owner of the White Wind Inn
in Provincetown and chairman of the Provincetown
Visitor Services Board. At the Oxford Guest
House, also in Provincetown, Stephen Mascilo,
one of the owners, reports that he already has
wedding ceremony bookings for the coming summer
and has actually had to turn away some requests.
Same-sex couples may be an even more
attractive market than their straight
counterparts. The Travel Industry Association
found that gay men tend to spend more on travel
than heterosexuals do, and most unions in the
Northeast involve out-of-state couples — in
Vermont, over 80 percent. And a study by the
School of Law of the University of California,
Los Angeles, found New Jersey alone will make
over $102 million annually from same-sex unions.
Allowing unions may also make a state seem
more same-sex friendly, attracting more gay and
lesbian travelers, over all. According to an
analysis last year by Community Marketing, a
research firm, an overwhelming majority of gay
and lesbian travelers say gay-friendliness is
the most important factor to them in choosing a
hotel.
“Legalization of same-sex unions does have a
financial impact,” Ms. Hamm said. “Legal
validation helps couples feel more confident
about ‘coming out’ with their relationships and
leads them to celebrate their commitments in
larger fashion.”
The novelty of same-sex ceremonies may be
wearing off in some places, so planners like Ms.
Smith have to become more inventive. “I had a
pagan wedding complete with a hand fasting,” she
said, referring to a ritual in which the
couple’s hands are tied together. “And then the
party traveled across Boston by trolley. I had a
science-themed wedding at the Museum of Science,
where they had the flowers in beakers.”
Other proprietors have started casting a
wider net. Mr. Docto advertises on the Web,
searching for clients nationwide who might
travel to Vermont.
“More and more gay and lesbian couples
inquiring about civil unions are from the
South,” Mr. Docto said. “Perhaps that’s the
geographic target: red states with little chance
of having same-sex marriage.”
In Provincetown, long a gay haven, inns play
on the area’s history to attract clients. A lot
of couples have “shared experiences/memories
created in Provincetown, and they want to make
their commitment in this very special
community,” Mr. Tosner said.
“I just love Provincetown, and I wanted to
have Laura experience a living, thriving gay
town,” Ms. McHugh said, noting that her partner
had never visited there. The event, for which
Ms. McHugh will arrive dressed in Irish tartans,
will mix a ceremony at the beach with a
reception at a beach house.
Massachusetts is the only state where gay
marriages are on the same footing as
heterosexual weddings (the civil unions
available in other states have a separate
status). Last year, Massachusetts hired a
marketing specialist to woo gay and lesbian
travelers.
And Vermont’s gay-friendly reputation had a
role in Ms. Sohn and Ms. Ballard’s choice. The
women decided they wanted to have their ceremony
there to honor it for being the first to
legalize civil unions. “It was really important
for us to reward Vermont in as many ways as
possible,” said Ms. Sohn, who tried to buy
almost everything for the event from Vermont
producers.
Yet even as the same-sex market heats up,
some planners are realizing that couples,
whatever their orientation, may not be so very
different.
After planning so many same-sex weddings, Ms.
Smith has found a constant theme. “Everyone,”
she said with a sigh, “wants a beach wedding.”
|