Hope & Politics -
The Perils of Assumption
Camp
By Diane Silver
March 1, 2008
Right now the LGBT community – particularly out here in
the wilds of the Midwest – is being strangled by an
assumption. It’s the idea that we’re wimps as far as
politics goes, that there aren’t enough of us and that we
don’t have enough allies to swing an election.
This assumption, held by both politicians and queer
folk, makes legislators too frightened to vote for fair
laws. It keeps many of us from spending time and money on
what we think is a lost cause.
This is why three recent reports are so important.
The first is a groundbreaking poll commissioned by the
Kansas Equality Coalition, where I serve as communications
chair. This is the only survey I’ve ever seen that
measured attitudes in Kansas about basic gay rights.
Although national polls have long confirmed, for example,
that Americans support ending discrimination in
employment, just about everyone (myself included) assumed
most Kansans were too conservative to go along with the
national norm.
The results of the Equality Coalition poll floored me.
Seventy-nine percent of those polled agreed that it is
not a good practice to “fire someone because they are, or
appear to be, gay or lesbian.” Of those who opposed
discrimination, 68 percent supported a law banning
workplace bias based on sexual orientation. Sixty-three
percent said they believed that cities should be allowed
to establish domestic partner registries.
Taken Jan. 19 and 20, the poll consisted of 500
interviews with Kansans who voted in the last two
elections. It has a 95 percent level of confidence.
The two other reports are demographic studies of the
lesbian, gay and bisexual communities in Kansas and
Missouri. Both were released in January by UCLA’s Williams
Institute.
Using U.S. Census data, the Williams Institute reported
that in 2005 an estimated 72,600 lesbian, gay or bisexual
individuals and more than 6,660 same-sex couples lived in
Kansas. Same-sex couples lived in every county in the
state, even the most remote. Seventeen percent of same-sex
couples were raising children.
In Missouri, the Williams Institute reported an
estimated 160,900 individuals and 14,700 same-sex couples.
About 20 percent had children. Lesbian, gay and bisexual
people were reported in every county in the state, no
matter how conservative.
These are just a few of the results of the Williams
Institute’s Census Snapshots, but they’re telling. LGB
people live in the districts of almost every legislator in
Kansas and Missouri. Every one of us has friends and
family who have a vested interest in gay rights. That
means every lawmaker, no matter how conservative, has to
answer to constituents who want us all to be treated
fairly.
The fact that the Williams Institute found that nearly
7,300 children are being raised by same-sex couples in
Missouri and Kansas is also revealing. Because of
inequities in the law, these kids have less access to
health insurance and more likelihood of having a parent
ripped away by the courts than their friends with
heterosexual parents.
These three reports are great first steps, but we have
a long way to go to get the information we need. We need
to include transgendered people in our studies. We need to
dig deeper into the attitudes of the typical Midwesterner.
We need to look further into demographics.
Given that we face job discrimination and our families
are still pummeled by the law, I wouldn’t be surprised if
the census vastly undercounts us. The LGB people with the
most to lose – parents and their children – are the ones
most likely to be undercounted.
Even with those deficiencies, though, these studies
show that we have both numbers and attitudes on our side.
Perhaps the most important lesson of all is that it is
time to let go and toss every single one of our old
assumptions aside.
Diane Silver helped found the Kansas Equality
Coalition. She blogs at www.hopeandpolitics.blogspot.com.
|