Not single, not
married: Similarities found for same-sex partners,
heterosexual couples
San Jose Mercury News
By Mike Swift
March 2, 2008Jeanine and Nichole Soterwood have made
the same emotional and financial commitments as most
married couples. They share a name. They have stood before
a justice of the peace and exchanged vows. They both own
their house and are the parents of a 4-year-old son,
Isaac.
But one thing about the Soterwoods is clearly not the
same. They aren't married, because they can't be. Instead,
they are among nearly 109,000 same-sex couples who live
together in California - double the number of any other
state. The most the Soterwoods could do is register with
the state as domestic partners - a step roughly 43,000
California couples have taken, and that the Soterwoods
moved specifically from Arizona to do.
As the gay marriage issue returns to center stage in
California, same-sex registered partners like the
Soterwoods have a direct personal stake in the issue. A
look at the growing body of data on these couples shows a
group that is larger in California than in any other
state, and - perhaps not surprisingly - that looks more
similar to married heterosexual couples in terms of
affluence, parenthood and other social measures.
Like many same-sex couples, the Soterwoods don't want
the similarities to end there.
"People are like, what does that mean, 'commitment
ceremony'? Just like, what does that really mean,
'domestic partnership'?" said Nichole Soterwood, who like
Jeanine is an engineer who works for Raytheon, the defense
contractor. "Well, Advertisement people know what marriage
means."
Activists say a majority of California's registered
partners, and a significant portion of same-sex couples
who live together but who aren't registered, would likely
marry if the California Supreme Court reversed the ban on
same-sex marriage.
"For many couples I know who are registered domestic
partners, they see it as an intermediate step to winning
full marriage equality," said Kate Kendell, executive
director of the National Center for Lesbian Rights, a
counsel for the plaintiffs in the same-sex marriage suit
the Supreme Court will hear Tuesday.
That would create a very loud chorus of "I dos,"
although it might also create a backlash from those who
believe gay marriage would undermine the institution.
Roughly one in six unmarried partner households in the
state are same-sex couples, among the highest share in the
nation, according to 2006 U.S. Census Bureau data. About
six in 10 of California's same-sex couples are gay men,
while four in 10 are lesbians.
The Census Bureau's estimates of the number of same-sex
couples is growing across the country - it's up 18 percent
in California since 2000. Still, the number remains small
compared with California's 6 million married couples, and
experts say the higher estimates don't necessarily mean
there are more same-sex couples.
"It's very likely that most of this is simply more
accurate reporting," said Gary Gates, a demographer at the
UCLA law school's Williams Institute. "It's certainly
possible that with increased social acceptance, more
lesbians and gay men are actually coupling and cohabiting,
but given the magnitude of the increases, it's very
unlikely that this is the primary cause."
A recent state survey of California's gay, lesbian,
bisexual and transgender population primarily done to
assess tobacco use also found that gay and lesbian couples
who live together - particularly those who are registered
partners - resemble married heterosexual couples in terms
of affluence, race and other social measures.
The data undermines the stereotype that gay men eschew
long-term relationships. Lesbians in California are more
likely to partner - 64 percent share a home with a partner
compared with 46 percent of gay men. But gay male
registered partners in California have been together
longer - an average of 12 1/4 years, compared with 8.9
years for lesbian registered partners, according to Gates'
analysis of the state-funded tobacco survey.
Registered lesbian partners are much more likely to
have children, however, with 34 percent of California
female registered partners reporting children compared
with just 2 percent of men.
California has about 14 percent of the nation's
same-sex couples, slightly higher than the state's share
of the total U.S. population, but census estimates of
same-sex couples are growing more quickly in the Midwest
and other places away from the coasts not traditionally
seen as centers of gay life. The census does not measure
the full gay and lesbian population, only the number of
same-sex couples who live together.
California may have a higher proportion of same-sex
couples than many states because of the early rise of
large and influential gay communities in San Francisco and
West Hollywood, communities that attracted those fleeing
the hostility of the rest of the country, Gates said.
Devin Baker and Art Adams of San Jose, who along with
the Soterwoods are among the roughly 1,300 registered
partners in Santa Clara County, were in the clerk's office
in San Francisco City Hall, their marriage application
half-filled-out, when the state Supreme Court halted the
same-sex marriages Mayor Gavin Newsom had begun in 2004.
Amid a tangle of photographers and family members,
their new wedding rings in hand, Adams remembers a city
official ordering, "You have to stop!"
Adams and Baker, both 43, watched as the heterosexual
couple in line behind them got married on the spot they
were to take their vows. Four years later, it remains a
bitter memory for the two men, the only South Bay
plaintiffs in the marriage lawsuit.
"It's just a very basic equality that values my
relationship the same as it would any heterosexual
relationship," said Baker, explaining his desire to marry.
"You don't have to explain it; you don't have to excuse
it; you don't have to give it different words. It's just
the same."
Contact Mike Swift at mswift@mercurynews.com or
(408) 271-3648.
|