Obama Makes Gay
Push, Hillary Pushes Back
The Advocate
By Kerry Eleveld
March 4, 2008The LGBT community becomes a
battleground as Obama tries to undercut Hillary's gay
support.
Barack Obama’s troops have been making a push in the
LGBT communities of both Ohio and Texas to cut into
Hillary Clinton’s long-standing support among gays and
lesbians before Tuesday's critical primary vote.
“Our goal was to really deputize the members of our
steering committee to organize our community in the major
metropolitan areas of those states,” said Eric Stern, an
Edwards-turned-Obama supporter who has been overseeing
LGBT field organizing in Ohio and Texas for the Obama
campaign. Polls show the two candidates in a statistical
dead heat in Texas, while Clinton has anywhere from 5- to
10-point edge in Ohio.
Comparing their strategy to the Bush/Cheney
get-out-the-vote efforts in Ohio in 2004, Stern said the
Obama camp has identified local LGBT folks to work
gayborhoods such as Montrose in Houston and the Short
North in Columbus.
“What they did, that we’re now doing, was they
deputized local people to go door-to-door and serve as
precinct captains, while the Kerry campaign was sending
people from out of state into Ohio to run the ground
game,” he said, adding that he believes that’s why the
Democrats lost the Buckeye State in 2004. “Ultimately, if
you’re talking to an undecided voter, if you’re their
neighbor down the street, they’re more likely to listen to
your argument and be persuaded by it. We’ve learned from
that.”
But just as quickly as Obama has been striking, Clinton
has been swinging back. No sooner had his campaign secured
four full-page ads in four separate gay weeklies in
Dallas, Houston, Columbus, and Cleveland, than she had
conducted a conference call with reporters from three of
the same weeklies. The Clinton camp also announced the
formation of a 38-member LGBT steering committee in Ohio
last week.
And in Houston – which has the 10th largest gay
population in the nation – after the city's nonpartisan
GLBT caucus endorsed Obama last week, Clinton spent 20
minutes of her Friday evening answering questions from the
Houston Stonewall Democrats, who endorsed her on Saturday.
“It’s an exciting time down here in Texas, the most
exciting in my lifetime,” said 45-year-old Teresa Herrin,
president of Houston’s Stonewall chapter, her voice
cracking from the strain of too much politicking. Herrin
said they extended an offer to both candidates to speak
with their five-member executive board but that the Obama
campaign finally declined the offer at 10:00 a.m. Saturday
morning.
“One of our members is a strong Obama supporter, so it
was really disappointing,” Herrin said.
In terms of the Clinton call, Herrin added, “What
really surprised us was her passion – that she understood
the immediate need for our community.”
Within the first 100 days of her presidency, Herrin
said, Clinton promised to extend benefits to all same-sex
couples who work for the federal government with an
executive order, end “don’t ask, don’t tell,” and use the
bully pulpit to advocate for a fully inclusive ENDA and a
fully inclusive hate-crimes bill. (Herrin and her
executive board were not clear how Sen. Clinton would end
“don’t ask, don’t tell” – if by executive order or some
other means.)
Clinton also discussed how adamant she is about
allowing everyone in America to adopt children if they are
a qualified couple. “It was like she was indignant,”
Herrin said of Clinton’s manner while talking about
same-sex couples’ adoption rights. “Her voice just really
changed, and that was the part that surprised us – her
passion.”
On the Obama side, Randall Ellis, chairman of the
senator’s Texas LGBT steering committee, is equally as
enthused. “As Texans, we’re used to being told, ‘This is
your nominee, this is who you need to support,’” said
Ellis, who was quietly backing John Edwards until he
dropped out of the race. “People here aren’t used to being
asked the question, ‘Who are you supporting in the
primaries?’ We really don’t know what hit us – all the
sudden we’re a campaign stop.”
When the Obama campaign came knocking, Ellis, 38, was
already engaged in reelection campaigns for two of the
LGBT community’s “biggest allies” in the Texas state
legislature, Reps. Garnet Coleman and Jessica Farrar.
“They’re often vulnerable because they take stances on
LGBT issues, and so people challenge them in primaries,”
Ellis explained.
Ellis weighed his options for a couple weeks and
ultimately decided to go with Obama, partly because of his
stance for full repeal of the Defense of Marriage Act
(Clinton supports partial repeal), but there was something
more.
“It’s that certain je ne sais quoi,” Ellis said. “The
people that you look at as a leader need to give you that
sense of inspiration and hope, and that certainly is
evident in the Obama campaign. People play that off like
it doesn’t mean anything. But I think it means a lot.”
Ellis organized people this weekend to canvass in the
Montrose neighborhood of Houston. According to estimates
by demographer Gary Gates at the Williams Institute, that
zip code, 77006, has a GLB population density of about
eight times the national average – almost exactly the same
density as New York’s Chelsea district, while San
Francisco’s Castro holds about 20 times the national
average.
After meeting up Saturday at the Starbucks on Montrose
Blvd., the uniformed Obama volunteers dispersed to cafes,
bars, and street corners, initiating one-on-one
discussions and asking passers-by: Are you voting for
Obama? Are you going to caucus? Have you told your
friends?
Rebekah Lee, a volunteer from Bellingham, Wash.,
employed technology to give on-the-fence-voters a reason
to consider Obama – using her cell phone, she pulled up a
copy of Obama’s recent open letter to the GLBT community
posted on Bilerico.com. “I really believe in Barack for
our time,” said Lee. “He’s not afraid to answer a question
with an ‘I don’t know’ or give you the tough answer. I can
tell Barack wants the office to be able to serve people.”
And just as Montrose was on fire with activity, so was
the Short North in Columbus, where a gallery hop that
attracts thousands of people ensues the first Saturday of
every month. According to locals, Columbus has the
second-largest Pride celebration in the Midwest behind
Chicago.
Mary Jo Hudson, a Clinton supporter and the
highest-ranking LGBT official in the state as a member of
the governor’s cabinet, headed over to the gallery hop
with a crew of folks armed with buttons and stickers.
“That’s something we do in Columbus whenever we’re doing
outreach in campaigns,” she said.
Hudson, 46, also had about 70 people over to her house
on Saturday night for a rally with three Clinton
surrogates: Randi Weingarten, president of the United
Federation of Teachers; California state representative
Laura Richardson; and Brenda Berkman, the first female
firefighter in New York City.
Hudson, a long-time Clinton ally who served on the
Human Rights Campaign’s Board in the ‘90s, said she
reminds people that “from day one, the office of the first
lady was very inclusive and how she was an outspoken
advocate on inclusion and equality and stood up for the
LGBT community against the far right.”
The Obama camp also had a presence at the gallery hop
and, for the most part, Hudson said the back and forth
between the campaigns in Ohio has been collegial. “That’s
how we do things here in Columbus,” she said. “But when we
move to the general election – when that finally happens –
it will be important for national leadership to make sure
we’re all pulling together, because I’ve never seen
anything quite like this, with the two sets of strong
feelings out there.”
It’s what Cleveland-based Jason Lansdale felt as he was
assembling people to sign on to an op-ed in support of
Obama to be run in Ohio’s LGBT newspapers. “Just the
energy and the passion,” he said. “Obviously we wanted as
many signatures as possible. We went from five or six key
leaders in Ohio to almost 60 overnight. I was really
surprised.” Altogether, 53 LGBT leaders signed on to the
letter, which is currently running in this week’s issue of
Outlook Weekly in Columbus.
Lansdale, 31, typifies the on-the-ground warrior that
Eric Stern was looking to enlist in the Obama campaign.
He’s lived in every corner of the state, is a former
president of the Stonewall Democrats chapter of Central
Ohio in Columbus, cochaired the LGBT campaign in Ohio for
Kerry/Edwards in ’04, and was the LGBT coordinator for
Jennifer Brunner, Ohio’s current secretary of state.
Lansdale explains that Ohio has five distinct regions.
“The [Cleveland] Plain Dealer did a piece leading up to
the 2004 elections called ‘The Five Ohios’ – those being
the Northwest, Northeast, Southwest, Southeast, and
Central Ohio – about how really different they are
culturally and politically.”
For instance, the Southwest is pretty strongly
Republican with lots of evangelicals and an Air Force base
in Dayton; central Ohio used to tilt toward the GOP but in
the last couple presidential cycles, Columbus and Franklin
counties have gone Democratic (housing Ohio State
University with 50,000 students doesn’t hurt); and the
Northeast with cities like Cleveland and Akron has been a
bastion of the Democratic base. It’s a glimpse of the
challenge both campaigns faced in reaching vastly
different voters across both Ohio and Texas. Obama has
reportedly outspent Clinton on advertising at least
two-to-one in both states.
One of the big-selling points on Obama for Lansdale was
hearing him reference the LGBT community and homophobia in
a number of his speeches. “Obama includes the LGBT
community in his core message — he’s not afraid to say the
words gay and lesbian,” he says. “I’m not questioning
Hillary’s support – she has a wonderful track record of
support on our issues, but you don’t see her use the word
gay very often.”
Lansdale represented Obama as a surrogate during one of
three LGBT forums organized by the National Stonewall
Democrats in Cleveland, Dallas, and Houston last week. All
three events drew around 100 people or more, according to
Stonewall’s executive director, Jon Hoadley.
“Not bad on a Monday or Tuesday,” Hoadley said of the
attendance. “People were there and excited about being
Democrats – that’s such a sea change from what we’ve been
seeing in the past.”
Hoadley attended both the Houston and Dallas forums and
said one of the most interesting things at the events was
the line of questioning.
“We had the top LGBT policy advisers from both the
Clinton and Obama campaigns, and what was the first
question out the gate? Health care,” recounted Hoadley,
adding that the discussions around immigration and the
alternative minimum tax were as robust as those around
“don’t ask, don’t tell” and civil unions. “People were
looking for real policy answers on a whole host of
subjects. We even got to stump them sometimes.”
Jesse Garcia, president of the Dallas Stonewall
Democrats chapter, also attended the Dallas forum. “I love
that our community was able to think outside our own self
interests – we’re just like any other American, we’re
worried about the future of America and our standing in
the world.”
And that’s a message that Garcia, who is a fervent
Clinton supporter, has been advancing with his members as
well. “I keep reminding everyone, regardless of their
presidential choice, this a great opportunity to be
introducing yourself and saying ‘Hey, I’m a gay Democrat
and let’s see how we can work together to fix this
nation,’” said Garcia. “I think it’s important that we
start sensitizing other Democrats – because there’s good
Democrats and there’s so-so Democrats on our issues.”
The Dallas Stonewall chapter, which endorsed Sen.
Clinton, is the largest dues-paying Democratic club in
Dallas, with about 350 members. Garcia, 36, who joined the
club in 2000 when it stood at around 80 members, said the
club’s size is a direct result of the fact that the LGBT
community suffers continuous attacks in Texas.
“We have congressmen who introduce antigay legislation,
so we’re always on the defensive and ready to mobilize,”
he said.
Garcia is also sort of a “double threat,” as he puts
it, as both a gay and a Hispanic rights activist. He’s
been working to build a bridge between the two communities
and helped found the first predominately gay chapter of
the League of United Latin American Citizens (or LULAC),
which he calls “the Hispanic version of the NAACP.”
“The same people that came after us on banning same-sex
marriage turned around and reformed and are now going
after immigrants,” said Garcia. “It’s all about learning
from each other’s communities and sharing common
interests.”
Emily Kim and Mehgan Sellers contributed reporting
to this article.
|