One-Third Of Irish
Gay Couples in U.S.
Irish Voice
By Cahir O’Doherty
March 19, 2008
AN estimated 1,200 Irish-born men and women – roughly
one-third of Ireland’s gay couples — are living with a
same-sex partner in the U.S., according to a new research
paper from the Williams Institute, a public policy think
tank at the University of California Los Angeles Law
School.
The study found that more than 500 Irish-born same-sex
partners here are not U.S. citizens and would be among
those most likely to return to Ireland to take advantage
of the forthcoming civil partnership bill to be introduced
by Irish Minister for Justice and Equality Brian Lenihan
by March 31.
Gary Gates, senior research fellow at the Williams
Institute, told the Irish Voice, “Same-sex partnership
legislation could help to entice a very talented group of
Irish-born emigrants back to live and work in their
homeland. Our study found that 43% of Irish-born same-sex
partners living in the U.S. are college educated.”
Analyzing data from the U.S. Census Bureau, the study
found that two-thirds of Irish-born same-sex partners in
the country are women. The study also found that
Irish-born same-sex partners are highly educated, with
more than four in 10 (43%) possessing a college degree.
More than one in seven couples that include an
Irish-born partner (15%) are raising children. An
additional 2,000 same-sex couples are living in Ireland,
according to the recent study.
As the Irish government considers the details of the
civil partnership law, Gates added, “Irish policy makers
should look beyond their own shores when they consider the
possible effects of civil partnership legislation, some of
which might be very good for the Irish economy.”
In the U.S. the Williams Institute has recently
conducted a series of studies on the economic consequences
of a state implementing marriage or other forms of legal
recognition for same sex couples, providing data to
informs those debates.
Says Gates, “With help from the recent census data I
discovered that I could determine what portion of same sex
couples were Irish-born. But since Ireland does not permit
foreign-born partners of Irish people to work there, for
most same sex couples it is not an option to move back.
“In consequence, Ireland is missing out on highly
educated college graduates, the kind of talent that
Ireland hopes to attract, due to legislation that won’t
permit them to move home with their U.S.-born partners.”
Gates added that many same sex Irish and U.S. couples
find themselves in a legal bind. If they move to Ireland
then the U.S.-born partner doesn’t have status, but if
they move to the U.S. the Irish-born partner doesn’t have
status.
“Given that Irish and U.S. same sex couples have
relatively high educations, our data suggests that Ireland
is losing a creative class to the U.S.,” Gates said.
“It turned out that the Irish people in our study were
substantially more educated than the general immigrant
population in the U.S. that is Irish-born.”
Asked how he explains the high levels of education
among gay Irish and U.S. couples Gates replied, “I think
there are several possibilities that could account for it.
Gay people use education like other minorities have done
to hedge against discrimination.
“If you’re 18 and choosing between going to college or
becoming an auto mechanic – well, you’ll probably pick
college if you think you won’t be discriminated against.
It could also be because universities are broadly more
welcoming than other alternatives after high school.”
Gates argues that new civil partnership legislation in
Ireland could make it easier for global companies to move
lesbian and gay employees, their partners and families
from one country to another without risking the economic
penalties and logistic challenges associated with
non-recognition of their relationships.
“Without legal recognition, it can be difficult for
partners of gay and lesbian employees to obtain work
permits and they can be subject to challenge regarding
their parental rights,” Gates added.
The Irish government plans to introduce civil
partnership legislation this spring. The legislation will
provide same-sex couples with most of the rights and
obligations of marriage, but without the name.
Recent public opinion polls show that 84% of Irish
people are in favor of some recognition of same-sex
couples, while 53% would allow gay couples to marry.
The study can be downloaded from: http://www.law.ucla.edu/williamsinstitute/publications/IrelandReport.pdf
|