Study: Gay couples
in Ariz. lack resources
The Arizona Republic
By Kerry Fehr-Snyder
March 4, 2008
Gay and lesbian couples in Arizona generally make less
money, are less likely to own a home and have fewer
resources to raise children than their married
counterparts, according to a new study by the Williams
Institute at the University of California Los Angeles.
The results of the study being conducted state by state
are shattering many long-held stereotypes.
More than 16,930 same-sex couples lived in Arizona,
according to the mid-decade U.S. Census.
"Gay men earn less than straight men," said Adam
Romero, a public-policy fellow who co-authored the study.
"Even when you hold constant occupation, race, geography,
they earn less and that's something economists would call
discrimination."
Women in same-sex relationships earn more than married
women - $31,336 on average compared with $25,231. Romero
attributed this to married women stepping out of the
workforce more often to raise children.
"When you only look for households where children are
present, same-sex couples do much, much worse," he said.
Same-sex parents in Arizona have lower median household
incomes, $39,000 a year compared with $54,000 for married
couples.
Tina and Jennifer Merrell know that situation
firsthand.
"We're legal strangers," said Tina, a 37-year-old
chemical analyst for Freescale Semiconductor in Chandler.
"We can't get married so we can't participate in the
1,500 benefits and responsibilities that come along with
marriage."
The Merrells, who have been together since 1989, are
among the 18 percent of same-sex couples who are raising
children in Arizona. Only Jennifer has full parental
rights to Samantha, their 16-month-old daughter. Tina is
named as the child's guardian in a legal document that
must be renewed every six months.
"It's exasperating that we have to sign it every six
months," Tina said. "Fortunately, we have a pediatrician
who is very respectful and understanding if there's a
delay and Samantha has a doctor's appointment."
Their daughter is biologically related to Jennifer, who
conceived the child with sperm donated by a friend.
The friend, Frankie Ambrose, is involved in the
Samantha's life and watches the child at least one day a
week while the women work. He has renounced all parental
rights to the women.
Ambrose is also donating sperm so that Tina may become
pregnant with the couple's second child.
"One of the things about me carrying this child, and
for lack of a better word, being the breadwinner, I won't
have to pay that same penalty for the child's medical and
dental benefits," Tina said.
She estimated that they are penalized about $10,000 a
year to have Jennifer and her biological child on Tina's
health insurance. Tina is being taxed for her
domestic-partner benefits, and that differs from most
insurance coverage for married couples and families.
The study also found that same-sex couples have fewer
resources than married couples. For example, about 63
percent of same-sex couples own their homes in Arizona
compared with 81 percent of married couples.
The Merrells do own their own home in Ahwatukee, but
they say they do feel like they have fewer resources than
married couples. A sales auditor for a major department
store, Jennifer began working part time shortly after
Samantha was born.
"The same resources, definitely not," Tina said. "As a
gay couple, not only do we not have the financial
advantages of married couples, we sometimes don't have the
family resources and help."
|