California Braces
for ‘New Summer of Love’
The New York Times
By Patricia Leigh Brown
June 14, 2008
Correction Appended
SAN FRANCISCO — The groom was shopping for the perfect
diamond for his betrothed — the other groom. As Rey
Almeida, a 47-year-old elementary school principal,
perused the Equality Forever rings (a same-sex wedding
special at 40 percent off if purchased from June 16 to
June 26), he couldn’t help reflecting on the symbolism.
“We’ve been waiting for the right moment,” Mr. Almeida,
47, said of marrying his partner, Alan Pex, a 46-year-old
accountant who was initially as standoffish as Mr. Big on
“Sex in the City.” “Now there’s the possibility of a ring,
a ring that says, I want to marry you and spend the rest
of my life with you.’ ”
California is gearing up for the “new summer of love,”
as it is being dubbed here: the legalization of same-sex
marriage beginning at 5:01 p.m. Monday.
Unlike in Massachusetts, California’s new law does not
limit marriages to residents of the state, thus
resurrecting old postcard images of California as the
promised land. But instead of Edenic orange groves, the
new arrivals will be greeted with organic framboise
ganaches, Russian River honeymoon canoe trips and Gay Palm
Springs hotel packages with rose petals, Champagne, two
souvenir pillows embroidered with the couples’ first names
and aromatherapy candles at room check-in.
Faced with a wilted economy, water shortages and
sticker shock at the gasoline pump, many California
businesses are welcoming “the dinks” (double income, no
kids) with open arms. “It’s basically a godsend,” said
Daniel Doiron, the general manager of the Ingleside Inn in
Palm Springs, which is offering honeymoon specials from
$479 bargain basement (boutonnieres, 15-minute wedding, 20
guests) to the “Elizabeth Taylor” at $29,999 (poolside
villas, wedding cake and reception, ice sculptures,
flowers, sit-down dinner for 200 and three nights in the
honeymoon suite). “We’re just blessed to help.” Ten
couples from New York, Las Vegas and Phoenix have signed
up for the options.
According to Community Marketing Inc., a gay and
lesbian market research firm here, four of the top 10 gay
travel destinations are in California, with gay men and
lesbians spending $64 billion a year on domestic leisure
travel. The potential windfall of same-sex marriage was
underscored this week in a study by the Williams Institute
at the University of California, Los Angeles, School of
Law, which estimated that over three years, same-sex
nuptials would contribute $684 million to the state’s
wedding industry and $64 million to the state budget.
The study also predicted that half of California’s
102,639 gay couples would marry over the next three years,
as would 68,000 from out of state (including 12,000 from
New York).
Among them are Jeffrey Dreiblatt, 47, who works on the
Web team at PricewaterhouseCoopers, and William Walker,
44, a legal assistant, from Brooklyn, who fell in love in
the Borough Hall subway station 15 years ago while
standing in line to buy tokens. They plan to honeymoon at
an inn in Sonoma County after marrying in San Francisco on
Aug. 8.
“When I was younger, I didn’t understand the point of
getting married and replicating heterosexual life,” said
Mr. Dreiblatt. “But over the years, my thinking has
changed. The law in California and the implications for
New York spoke to us and said, ‘now is the time.’ ”
Many gay men and lesbians are taking a wait-and-see
attitude, said the Rev. Blane Ellsworth, an independent
nondenominational minister in Napa who also has a Web
site, Enchanting Elopements, listing equality-sensitive
businesses. There is still the memory of the euphoria, and
letdown, in 2004, when nearly 4,000 same-sex couples stood
in line to marry in San Francisco, only to have the
marriages nullified by the state five months later.
Mr. Ellsworth said those he has dealt with “are pretty
smart business people.”
“They’re saying if they’re going to invest in a nice
service and wedding, ‘I’m going to wait until it’s a sure
thing,’ ” he said.
“We’re hoping our rights don’t get taken away again,”
said Megan Marteny, 23, who was sipping Champagne one
recent night with her partner at a wedding expo held by
the Golden Gate Business Association, a
gay/lesbian/bisexual/transgender chamber of commerce.
In contrast to the experience in 2004, which had a
spontaneous, storm-the-castle,
free-tickets-to-the-Grateful-Dead quality, with hundreds
of couples standing in line in the rain overnight, there
is a palpable sense of impending permanence this time.
Ed Schultz, a social worker who became domestic partner
to Steve Berlin last year, plans to go to City Hall on
July 10. “Marriage has a certain dignity,” Mr. Schultz
said. “When I go to work and say, ‘I’m domestically
partnered,’ that’s something different than saying, ‘I’m
married.’ ”
Charlotte Fiorito, a wedding photographer who
specializes in same-sex unions, says she did “the 2004
crush in our rain ponchos. Now, a lot of people are
planning the kind of weddings they have been waiting their
whole lives for.”
Among them are James H. Bainton and Jeffrey Rueda, both
40 and doctors, who were about to send out letterpress
invitations to their commitment ceremony at a Napa Valley
vineyard when the Supreme Court ruled last month that gay
men and lesbians had a constitutional right to marry. The
invitation to their “commitment ceremony” was quickly
changed to “wedding.”
“We’re still in the shaping mode,” Mr. Bainton said of
the nuptials, with 100 guests, to take place beside a pond
in fields of sage and lavender at the height of August
tomato season. “This increases the meaning of it. It feels
like we’re sitting here making history.”
While not quite a gold rush, businesses like Enchanted
Elopements and myqueerwedding.com are popping up.
And across the state, there is a sense of the birth of
new rituals. Steve Pougnet, the openly gay mayor of Palm
Springs, plans to hold a citywide “marriage festival” on
June 21, having been deputized two weeks ago by the county
clerk. He has two dozen weddings lined up and is planning
his own in the fall. Jan Felshin, 76, and Edrie Ferdun,
71, retired professors who live on Fire Island in New
York, have been together 49 years. At their wedding in
Mandeville Canyon, in Los Angeles, they will be joined by
four other lesbian couples.
Not surprising, along with new rituals have come new
etiquette questions. Couples whose marriages were
nullified in 2004, like Joyce Feltham and Dorian Leslie
Duren of Palo Alto, are wondering how to handle their
“encore” wedding, a new breed here as couples embark on
their second or third public pledge to the same person.
“How do we tell people who brought gifts the first time
not to feel obligated to bring another one?” Ms. Duren
asked.
Peggy Post, the etiquette expert and author, who is
based in Vermont, said the legalization of same-sex
weddings, if it held, was bound to bring about changes in
the ritual, the same way, she said, that brides now walk
down the aisle with stepfathers, not just their fathers,
and that a white dress has come to signify “the color of
joy,” not just virginity.
So it will be too, when same-sex couples are pronounced
“spouses for life.”
Armistead Maupin, one of the city’s most famous
authors, became married in Vancouver, British Columbia,
last year to his partner, Christopher Turner, and will
probably marry him again in California, he said.
“Straight people have grown up thinking they’re
entitled to a fairy-tale wedding,” Mr. Maupin said. “One
of our great advantages as gay people is that we’ve been
forced to forge relationships without that fantasy. In
doing so, we’ve figured out what’s at the core.”
He continued, “Our relationships supported us during
the AIDS epidemic. We know what it means to have another
person stand by you.”
Correction: June 17, 2008 An article on Saturday
about preparations by the California tourist industry for
an influx of gay couples planning to marry this summer
misstated the occupation of a man who plans to marry in
San Francisco in August. Jeffrey Dreiblatt is part of the
Web team at PricewaterhouseCoopers; he is not a Web
designer. The article also misstated the given name of his
partner. He is William Walker, not Willie.
|